I posted my reply directly after reading Alexis’ first comment and before reading the rest of this thread (this is what I get for being away for a few days).
I didn’t expect the brouha that flared up in the last two or three pages of this thread.
Anyway, I want to comment one final time on it but Alexis please just ignore my post and focus on Fallen London and The Sunless Sea (1/6th of the way there after only six hours!).
I wouldn’t be surprised if between the wikis out there all the dialogue from Mass Effect is available online; not that there is that much of it in the first place.
Obviously the big difference is that Fallen London is a based only on text and static images and doesn’t have these flashy moving images or interactive ‘twitch’ gameplay that Mass Effect has. And Mass Effect 2 had huge plot holes but I digress…
I do think the value of wikis should not be underestimated; MMO’s would not have even a fraction of their player-base without wikis. Side note: it can be useful (though costly) to have your own (developer administrated) wiki but you’ll always have people creating their own as well.
Obviously you can get more of the total Fallen London experience just by reading the wikis than almost any other game. But I doubt it’s enough for anyone not to play the game because of this.
And as others have said: being able to read about certain, fate-locked or not, items/stories can be enough to push people in that direction.
The wiki would still work when you’d remove the flavour text and just summed up the items, connections, etc. lost/gained every action but it would lessen my enjoyment of the game, not the wiki.
It’s nice to be able to read the text again, assuming you even did the first time when a hasty click can lock you out sometimes. And yes, the journal is not very useful for this and giving it search functionality, etc. would cost you a lot of resources that I’m sure most of us would like to see spent on Fallen London proper and/or The Sunless Sea.
Anyway, I do understand that Fallen London is in a special position when it comes to wikis but I do hope things can remain as they are.
Would any of the forum readers happen to be a UK intellectual property lawyer? :D