[quote=Clifton Royston]Speculations on the Hours
I should say right out that I expect most of these speculations into the possible natures of some hours, including some barely mentioned hours, to be way off. But… if all goes well, we’ve still got months to wait for the game. I thought I’d play around a little with tabulating what little information we’ve got, and adding uninformed speculation to the mix.
There are several parts to these speculations:
- One is to assume that the number of the Hour might have some correspondence to an associated hour of the day. It may not! Their numbering may be completely unrelated to their ordering, and we don’t even know if the Hours have a correspondence to time as we know it. (Except for Moth, where we’re told explicitly.)[/li][li]A second is to assume that the Hour’s number might have some connection to the corresponding cards of the traditional Tarot trumps. Again, it may not! (In one case, we have an intriguing association for the Witch and Sister, but that might be just that one card.) But perhaps the Tarot trump can give us a bit of clue into its flavor or personality, or something to build on.[/li][li]A third is to assume that the Hour’s name, and meanings we can independently learn for that name, e.g. by wild Google searches, browsing Borges, or what-have-you, may have some association with its nature or flavor. Again, that may be as wrong as assuming that a guy named Rex (or girl named Regina) necessarily has a royal demeanor and sense of dignity. But we’ve got to start somewhere, and we have far too much time to kill between now and the initial release, right?[/li][li]Remember: "Some Hours are malevolent. Some just embody passions too strong for human life. All are very dangerous."
So here we go:
0. The Moth.
Hour of time = 12:00 midnight (official lore)
Possible Tarot correspondence = 0 The Fool. (Air; The Fool can symbolize questing, seeking, so chaos and yearning is a good fit!)
Lore: "The Moth’s Hour is midnight. It is the first God-who-was-blood. It seeks among the trees of the Wood; it beats within the skull; it is dappled."
“The Glory is a question, and the Moth always answers Yes. …" [De Horis vol I]
The principle of Moth: "I knew a man who captured moths in a bell-jar. On nights like this, he would release them one by one to die in a candle. [Moth is the wild and perilous principle of chaos and yearning]" Associated with Passion.
Further things we think we know: The Moth is not simply an expression of the insect; it has creepy hands.
It’s an Hour of the Wood. "This volume deals mostly with the Hours of the Wood: the Moth, the Black-Flax, the Ring-Yew, among others." [De Horis vol I]
Certain people can have affinity with the Moth. "I ran crying into the night and I recollected myself only curled among the roots and blades of the Wood. To that episode, I ascribe my affinity with the Moth…” [‘Around 1890, in the Third History…’]
Search: Not even going to try searching this; "moth" will pull up far too much to sort through.
Speculation: Moth seems to be what this game is all about, doesn’t it? Impossibly powerful yearning, and yearning for the impossible. To quote Archy, but at the same time i wish / there was something i wanted / as badly as he wanted to fry himself. Speaking of which, I’m still hoping to have another dream about The Wood.
I. The Door in the Eye.
Hour of time = possibly 1:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = I. The Magician (Mercury)
Lore: "The Door in the Eye, which illuminates, which navigates, which is not compassionate. The Watchman is the Door in the Eye. He opens the way for the willing and for the unwilling. He is often the first Hour that we supplicate. He is always in white."
This associates the Door in the Eye with the Watchman, hence the rite of the Watchman’s Sorrow
"EACH HOUR HAS ITS COLOUR. EACH FLAME HAS ITS FUEL. I’ve walked behind the Watchman; I’ve seen his shadow on the stone. This is the first step in understanding the shaping of fate. If I had more time, I could learn to walk the Mansus; gather disciples; find the star-shattered fane; watch the Hours walk; grow Long." [One victory condition, alpha]
Search: Can’t find anything seemingly meaningful, other than some wonderfully scrambled metaphors ("Working at _ is a great way to get your foot in the door in the eye industry") and references to a historical novel "The Eye in the Door".
Speculation: "I’ve walked behind the Watchman" somehow suggests to me that it would turn out a Bad Business Indeed if he were to see you. (cf. Neepy Thang and the Bird of the Difficult Eye.) Even so, the Watchman as Magician seems a plausible correspondence, offering a risk worth taking to gain an introduction to the powers of the Mansus. ("the first Hour that we supplicate", "the first step in understanding the shaping of fate.")
II. The Black-Flax.
Hour of time = possibly 2:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = II. The High Priestess (Moon)
Lore: "The Glory is a question… The Black-Flax’s answer is No, and that is always its answer.” [De Horis vol I]
It’s an Hour of the Wood. "This volume deals mostly with the Hours of the Wood: the Moth, the Black-Flax, the Ring-Yew, among others." [De Horis vol I]
It’s an older Hour, and opposes the Crowned Growth. "I thank the Sun for the Horned Axe, the Black-Flax, the other older Hours. Without them I wonder whether we might not all be the Growth." [‘Around 1890, in the Third History…’]
Search: I can’t find anything seemingly meaningful by searching for black flax or Black-Flax, just information about decorative varieties of flax plants or flax clothing.
Wild speculation: On that "No"… perhaps this Hour’s nature is that it seeks to freeze and preserve things exactly as they are, or allow them to change only at a glacial rate? That would make it an opposite of Moth, in one sense, and also make it an opponent of the Crowned Growth. Or perhaps (drawing from the High Priestess symbolism) it seeks to protect Mysteries and keep them from investigation and encroachment.
AA: Since the Moth answers "Yes" to the question of the Glory and seeks the Light, to a seemingly self-destructive degree (Moth to the candle flame), I think the Black-Flax’s "No" indicates that it actively moves away from or avoids the Light. Which seemingly puts it at odds with not only the Moth but also the rest of the Woods, which arises from the foundations of the world and reaches towards the Glory.
III. The Ring-Yew.
Hour of time = possibly 3:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = III. The Empress (Venus, femininity)
Lore: It’s an Hour of the Wood. "This volume deals mostly with the Hours of the Wood: the Moth, the Black-Flax, the Ring-Yew, among others." [De Horis vol I]
Search: I can’t find anything seemingly meaningful, other than bow-makers discussing the importance of following the rings in the wood when making a bow from yew. Or is it about yews planted in a ring, as one does, if one is a Druid?
No speculations as yet.
IV. The Thunderskin.
Hour of time = possibly 4:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = IV. The Emperor (Aries)
Lore: "The Thunderskin is the Heart Relentless, who does not permit conclusion. With the Mother of Ants, he is among the chiefest Gods-from-flesh. He cannot be stilled; he demands the dance; he is beaten, like a drum. Red and blue are his colours. He is heard in the Wood below the world."
Principle of Heart: "The Heart Relentless beats to protect the skin of the world we understand." [The Heart is the principle that continues and preserves]
The Thunderskin is canonically the source or patron of coffee. (Thanks to Anne Auclair for her Lore question!)
Search: can’t find anything seemingly meaningful, just a lot of game skins, phone case skins etc.
Wild speculation: "He demands the dance." Might one of the Thunderskin’s particular dangers be as the source of the Tarantella, the fairy-tale-like (but historically attested) contagious mental disease causing people to dance themselves to death? Perhaps then along with coffee, he would also be the source or patron of MDMA and other stimulant drugs?
AA: Presumably depressants and hallucinogens are patronized by opposing powers, as they make you still or take you out of the world. I also wonder if the Heart Relentless being the patron of coffee means that it is actively hostile towards dreaming. For it is within dreams that you glimpse what lies beneath the skin of the world, and the Heart wants the skin preserved.
V. The Mother of Ants.
Hour of time = possibly 5:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = V. The Hierophant (or the Pope in older decks) (Taurus)
Lore: "I need rest and nourishment, if I am to recover. But the Mother of Ants looks kindly on wounds." [Injury text, alpha]
"To open the way, one must first open oneself. This practice outlines that opening, in the name of the Mother of Ants." [Consent of Wounds]
"…the Mother of Ants … is among the chiefest Gods-from-flesh." (Lore text for the Thunderskin)
Principle: probably Knock, due to Consent of Wounds? but not completely confirmed.
"The Knock permits no seal and no isolation. It thrusts us gleefully out of the safety of ignorance. [the knock is the principle that opens doors and exposes secrets]"
Search: We’ve been kicking this one around already. From the St. Agnes reference in the Addendum from ‘Hints to Travellers in Italy’, we’ve teased out a connection to Anguitia/Agnitia, a serpent-associated healing goddess of Roman times. More directly, there is or was a New World snake called ‘Mother of Ants’ by the Aztecs, as reported by an early Spanish naturalist. Some online sources call the amphisbaena (serpent with head on both ends) the Mother of Ants, but even if the amphisbaena association is a mistake as I think, there’s definitely some connection with serpents.
Speculation: Can’t come up with anything yet, though I feel we should be able to from what we have.
VI. The Witch and Sister.
Hour of time = possibly 6:00 am (I want it to be midnight, but that’s the Moth’s)
Possible Tarot correspondence = VI. The Lovers. (Gemini, and the Witch and Sister is associated with the Geminiad, so this definitely works.)
Lore: "The Witch-and-Sister unites what is at rest. She is sought at the water’s edge and beneath the moon. She cannot be touched; she cannot be separated; she is pearl, coral, amber."
"They are seen in dreams, particularly when one dreams before a cracked and uncovered mirror. On nights of the greater moon they arise from the lake and generate unwanted multiple births, inspire follies of passion, and blend flesh to flesh. The locals turn for protection to St Agnes, but I have seen that they also make poppets – of two heads and four arms – to placate the lake-witches."
Opposed by the Mother of Ants: "The locals turn for protection to St Agnes… In my dizziness and fear my Italian had all but abandoned me, but I understood this: ‘the Twins! You have kissed the Twins!’" [Addendum from ‘Hints to Travellers in Italy’]
Search: Didn’t find anything relevant, outside of CS links.
Speculation: We’ve got a little taste of this Hour now - their nature governs forces including lust, mad sex, multiple or conjoined births, but also watery depths (coral and pearl), gems resulting from transformation (pearl and amber), and perhaps tentacled creatures (note the border of the card image.) But I still don’t feel like we have a clear picture of her/them.
IX. The Cartographer of Scars.
Hour of time = possibly 9:00 am.
Possible Tarot correspondence = IX. The Hermit (Virgo)
Lore: nothing at all as yet?
Search: Can’t find anything relevant.
Nothing to speculate on as yet.
XII. The Sun-In-Rags.
Hour of time = possibly noon (which sort of works, for a Sun god of sorts.)
Possible Tarot correspondence = XII. The Hanged Man. (Water; The Hanged Man can symbolize self-sacrifice, which might fit with those beautiful endings.)
Lore: "The Sun-in-Rags concludes endings beautifully. He is usually reckoned one of the Gods-from-Light; but Julian Cosely (the seventeenth-century magus and reputed immortal) has indicated he should in fact be numbered among the Gods-from-blood. He burns; he is distant; he is not as he was. He wears gold and red."
"SOL INVICTUS. This was the title of Mithras, but also Hercules, Apollo, and of course Heliogabalus / Elagabulus, who was briefly worshipped in Rome. Briefly along the Second History, anyway. His mortal incarnation was a pretty sorry specimen, although he’s believed to have passed the Stag Door, and at least to have been accounted a Know." [Kickstarter announcement email]
Search: It’s easy to find a plethora of material on the mortal Marcus Antoninus/Elagabalus, as we’ve been discussing. He came rapidly to a bad (but interesting) end - he could be the prototype of "Live fast, die young, leave a good-looking corpse." Other characteristics of the mortal Antoninus Elagabalus in our history: mentioned by Borges in ‘The Lottery in Babylon’, where he’s claimed to have held lotteries for his dinner guests; deified briefly after his death, like several of the more successful Emperors; famously decadent and spend-thrift; bisexual and possibly transgender - some biographers claimed he referred to himself as a woman, and to one of his lovers as his husband. Who knows whether any of this bears on the Hour, though.
One nice hit on ‘Sun in Rags’ is the John Donne poem, ‘The Sun Rising’ ("Busy old fool, unruly sun…") which contains the phrase "Nor hours, days, months, which are the rags of time." Hmmm.
Speculations: This Hour would seem wonderful to be associated with - for a little while. Might the existence of the Sun-in-Rags have something to do with the Sun itself having been "split" as noted in the Lore for the Forge of Days and Red Grail? Are the rags of the Sun-In-Rags the "rags of time"? "Briefly along the Second History, anyway" implies a couple of interesting possibilities to me: 1) We’re living in the Second History. 2) In another History or Histories, the god Elagabal/Elagabalus was worshipped for much longer, or perhaps still is.
AA: Maybe the Forge of Days and the Red Grail teamed up to split the Sun. That would explain why the Sun-in-Rags is associated with both Light and Blood.
XVII. The Red Grail.
Hour of time = possibly 5:00 pm.
Possible Tarot correspondence = XVII. The Star (Aquarius; that correspondence really doesn’t work for me!)
Lore: "The Red Grail seeks to devour and be devoured." [Kickstarter page]
“We must devour to be devoured. We cannot be undevoured, as we cannot be unborn.” [The Orchid Transfigurations]
"I need rest and nourishment, if I am to recover. But when my mouth waters, when my vision swims, I see the red cup, and now and then it will speak to me." [Starvation card text]
"Here am I, alone on the night of my victory, my end. The Grail has opened its mouth. It will not forget my savour. It will not forget." [Victory text, web prototype]
"Hersault says the Red Grail split the sun. Coseley proposes it was the Forge of Days. They both agree that now, it’s sunset at noon." [Noonstone text, web prototype]
The principle of Grail – Hunger, lust, the drowning waters. "The principle of the Red Grail demands to be fed."
Search: A passing reference to the ‘Red Grail’ in the Charles Williams poem ‘Son of Lancelot’, in a context where red means hunger - very interesting. Might be more to find, if we dig further.
Speculations: In the web prototype, of course, we learn a lot about the character of the Red Grail and one form of dangerous relationship to it - opening ones mind to it is spectacularly deadly for oneself and others, in full apocalyptic style. I speculate that a less disastrous relationship with the Red Grail might be possible for the particularly skilled and well-balanced mage who could keep its allure at arms’ length, at least for a while, though it will always be a particularly dangerous Hour. It is at least plausible to some of the Know or Long that it is powerful enough to damage the sun.
XXII. The Forge of Days.
Hour of time = possibly 10:00 pm (though I kind of want this to be sunset or dawn?)
No traditional Tarot correspondence by number (though I kind of wish it were XXI. The World.)
Lore: “Even the Sunne can be divided, though it require the Forge of Dayes for its division.” [‘Six Letters on Necessity’, Coseley]
"Mouth the scorching words and dream of smoke." [Meditate on the Forge of Days, web prototype]
"In this past, a score or more of Longs were made. They brokered peace with the Forge of Days, long enough to set England on a path of early conquest and eventual destruction. The Forge itself devoured the greatest among them." [‘A History of the War of the Roads’, web prototype]
"Hersault says the Red Grail split the sun. Coseley proposes it was the Forge of Days. They both agree that now, it’s sunset at noon." [Noonstone text, web prototype]
Principle of Forge: ‘Fire,’ I once read, ‘is the winter that warms and the spring that consumes.’ [The Forge of Days transforms and destroys]
Search: Nothing relevant, other than links back to Cultist Simulator posts. (First mentioned in July 2016, before the first web prototype.)
Speculation: "The winter that warms and spring that consumes" is fascinating - at first glance one might read it the natural way (it warms the winter) but it’s saying the opposite. It’s clear from the very little we know that this must be another particularly dangerous Hour. Cosely (a Know and probably a Long) argues that it split and damaged the sun, and it "devoured" the greatest among a group of powerful Longs. If the Forge seeks to transform and destroy, then that’s surely not going to be pleasant for those so transformed. As yet, though, we don’t know much about its character (other than hungry for fuel) or what it can do by way of transformation, though clearly its power can greatly affect history.
AA: It might also have ultimately consumed Coseley as well. It’s one of the last things he wrote about before…well, whatever happened to him ("Coseley’s tone is urgent – as if he suspected he might have little time left."), and his letters are explicitly about the costs of the invisible arts…
XXVII. The Crowned Growth.
Probably a secret hour, not one of the regular 24. (This is probably a good thing from what we know of it.)
No possible Tarot correspondences.
Lore: "I shall say there was a river flowing through the door. It was not a river, and neither was it pus, nor joy, but when I tried to articulate it better, my pen snapped in my hand. … The Rising Spider wishes dominion, but the Growth wishes only to infect and become. I do not believe the Bounds are the limbs of the House, but I must aver that the Dead that night had become the limbs of the Crowned Growth." [‘Around 1890, in the Third History…’]
Search: First hit is the blog lore post ‘Around 1890…’ followed by the discussions in here. Apart from that, things about mammal tooth growth patterns, various trees’ growth (Eastern Redbud, Ponderosa Pine, Cox Orange Apple), business awards, and again something about bowmaking; nothing that seems relevant.
Speculation: More terrible than evil - the Hour of cancer (the disease not the sign), of Internet flash worms, of infectious memes, of the hive mind.
The Beachcrow. Unknown number (possibly XI or XIII?)
Possible Tarot correspondences, XI Justice (or Temperance), or XIII Death.
Lore: nothing at all as yet?
Search results: Nothing suggestive - lots of photos of crows on the beach; an interrogation of a serial killer; some nice poems by Ursula K. LeGuin. http://www.ursulakleguin.com/Poetry-Crows.html Nothing too revealing or provoking an Aha! moment, but the poems are good.
Really wild speculation: Raven? Is that you? (Probably not, seems too obvious.)
The least-known hours as yet:
The Lionsmith. Unknown number.
Lore: "The Lionsmith makes monsters, that he may grow strong and stronger." [Kickstarter main page]
Search: Nothing that seems helpful or relevant; mostly turns up references to jazz stride pianist Willie "The Lion" Smith, who I’ll have to check out.
Nothing to speculate on as yet.
The Colonel. Unknown number.
Lore: "THE COLONEL IS SCARRED. THE COLONEL IS BLIND. THE COLONEL CANNOT BE EVADED." [email, early web page?]
Search: Not going to try searching this; I expect it will pull up too much.
Nothing to speculate on as yet.
The Flowermaker. Unknown number.
Lore: "THE FLOWERMAKER CANNOT HARM YOU. THE FLOWERMAKER CANNOT FIND YOU. THE FLOWERMAKER HAS WHAT YOU DESIRE." [email, early web page?]
No other mentions I’m aware of.
Search: Possibly connected? In the 1800s, flowermakers were the people who made artificial decorative flowers, and often ended up poisoned by arsenic pigments and dyes. https://books.google.com/books?id=re4pCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA94&lpg=PA94&dq=The+Flowermaker
Nothing to speculate on as yet.
The Rising Spider. Unknown number.
Lore: "The Rising Spider wishes dominion…" [‘Around 1890, in the Third History…’]
Mentioned in passing as hypothetical DLC in a Kickstarter update. "then if I have a better idea a year from now (‘Rising Spider DLC would be way more interesting than Crowned Growth DLC’) …"
No other mentions I’m aware of.
Search: Can’t find anything relevant as yet. The quoted lore piece itself already turns up by page 5 of a Google search.
Speculation: I like spiders, generally speaking, and yet even with nothing to go on, I suspect that the Rising Spider might be one of the more malevolent Hours.
The Horned Axe. Unknown number.
Lore: It’s an older Hour, and opposes the Crowned Growth. "I thank the Sun for the Horned Axe, the Black-Flax, the other older Hours. Without them I wonder whether we might not all be the Growth." [‘Around 1890, in the Third History…’]
No other mentions I’m aware of.
Search: There was a type of ancient Norse axe called Snaghyrnd Øx, translated "Snag-Horned Axe", and in general the points of a curved-bladed Viking battle-axe may have been referred to as horns.
Wild speculation: Does this Hour embody the ancient battle weapon? Is it an Hour of battle itself?
I think I’m done. Go wild.
[Edited to incorporate many of Anne Auclair’s additions and comments]
edited by cliftonr on 9/22/2017[/quote]
The Colonel sounds like it is the hour of the edge end it could be another name for an hour.