So, I currently have a plan. I want to know if anyone has ever gotten to the end of Mr Eaten’s quest, turned back and got the item… then did it all again?
That’s not possible. The item locks you out of going North ever again while none of your progress is erased. So you can’t start from the beginning, but you can’t go North either.
Unless you mean “doing it all again” on another account. I’m sure there’s people who’ve done that.
Ah, a pity. I suppose I’ll move onto plan B, getting some other big achievements as well as Mr Eaten’s quest. Thank you for letting me know!