I’ve found this thread and the arguments in it to be quite interesting, so to begin with I’d like to thank you all for sparking such an interesting conversation, good points have been raised all around. However, there is something that’s been troubling me as we’ve attempted to explain the actions of the Captivating Princess. As of the moment, her actions during the storylet where you share honey with her during the Feast of the Exceptional Rose have been glossed over for the most part. As such, I shall raise a point that we need to address if we wish to understand the Captivating Princess in her entirety. Just in case you haven’t seen it, here’s the text for the storylet I am referring to.
[quote]"A delightful dream"
She is charming. She finds you charming. Would you care to share a little honey after the dessert? You would? Splendid.
Envious eyes and three chaperones follow your departure to a private chamber. You share a dream of bright skies, sunlight and endless lush grass. She whispers in your ear. "There are other honeys," she says. "Are you the one who will share them with me?" Her eyes gleam red, here in the field you dream together. Something terrifying has leached into the air. But she is mesmerising.
You wake in Watchmaker’s Hill. The air of your thoughts is clouded deep red. There is a taste like blood in your mouth. The Princess is gone.[/quote]
To be candid, I find the implications of her actions in this storylet are nothing short of horrifying. The Princess spikes your honey with Gaoler’s Honey, she essentially roofies the player. By doing this, she tricks you into violating the mind of another, leafing through their memories like pages in a book. If we are to excuse the Princess for using Red Honey herself, justifying it by saying that that she has her own reasons just as Feducci has his for being a slave trader during the war with Hell, then we must evaluate her actions here in themselves without the Honey.
Removing Red Honey from the equation as it is just the means she uses, we are left with the fact that she violates the player’s consent, she does not even consider it a real factor. In the past, I have always felt that this fact has been downplayed or ignored by many in the community, whether they are fans of the Captivating Princess or not, and I think this is a major issue. I believe that if the Captivating Princess was male, if she was the Captivating Prince, this would not be overlooked. In fact, I think far more people would be horrified and outraged by this storylet. But this should not be true, no matter the Captivating Princess’ gender, no matter her reasons, no matter how the view of her character is shifted, I cannot in good conscience, nor should anyone else be able to, excuse what she does in this storylet. Even if we ignore the terrifying nature of the substance used, we are still left with an act that makes me feel sick to my stomach.
If one wants to understand the Captivating Princess, the true nature of her character, or even why some individuals such as myself were so against voting for her in the Mayoral Election, one only needs to look as far as this story to find the answers. Thank you for your time.