There’s some content in the wiki from Seeking that demonstrates that it’s a little of both.[li]
On the one hand, there’s an explicit reference to it being "Mr. Candles", mentioned on the "Give up your Enigma" text on the Queen of Inks card, and some old content from a Mr. (Eaten) Sacks visit a few years back.
On the other hand, there’s no shortage of hints in Seeking that it’s a seven-letter word (SEVEN IS THE NUMBER) in the Correspondence. Problematic, since normal materials generally (always?) burst into flame after at best six symbols have been inscribed. Examples include the "In your dreams, you hear a voice echoing hollowly each night" card that starts the Seeking plot.
IMO, the act of utterly effacing the name of something is the critical act here. There’s historical precedent for the belief that erasing the name of something effectively destroys it; chiseling the cartouches of unpopular Pharaohs off monuments was thought to be equivalent to attacking them in the afterlife - and the "In your dreams, you hear a voice echoing hollowly each night" card result has you finding a place where the Name has been chiseled off…
[ul][li]He’s waiting for a reckoning that shall not be postponed indefinitely. i.e., he’s waiting for his time.[/li][li]He’s lurking, dead and drowned. You can’t see him, not without making a very bad decision and dooming yourself.[/li][li]Finding his name gives your character an ending, albeit a bad one. Perhaps one can argue that he’s the endpoint of the FL franchise.
[/li][li]His domain is candles, shinin’ in the dark.[/li][/ul]Therefore:
You would have thought with 999 watchful Mr Eaten would have seen this whole thing coming. After all if 200+ watchful is enough for an impossible theorem 999 watchful should have been enough for Eaten to realize that all his space-bat-friends hated him. edited by The Angry Pirate on 7/13/2016