[quote=PSGarak]
I go the message "has not changed from 1 because it’s already higher than 0." I chose not to give it to her, because I need the Dreaded and was afraid to lose it. If you end up getting it back afterwards, I would probably choose different next time. [/quote]
Mechanical spoiler:
I chose to give the Mildewy Mask (shadowy +6 ,dreaded +2) to Virginia and , although I had not been in possession of the object before visiting the Waswood, the Waswood still gave it to me at the end (Gained it once , lost it to Virginia, gained it again , all in the Waswood in the span of about 10 actions).