Folks, could Madame Petrovsky, over in Neath, actually be Phoebe? I’m suspicious!
Can you clarify? You could be alluding to any of a large number of people I know nothing about.
I don’t remember anyone already mentioned in the game, and I can’t tell if you’re thinking about someone mythical, fictional, or actual.
Personally, I always connected her to Madame Blavatsky, which I think has been mentioned in these forms before.
as for Madame Petrovsky’s question—whether or not she is Phoebe, from the hunter Keep!
Tenshi, I want to know what led you to even ponder this. I have not seen anything linking the two besides them sharing a portrait that’s also used for generic characters in multiple places, so what do you see that connects the two?
The image of Madame Pretovisky is actually an image of Phoebe!
@Diptych Please help me and answer my question!
You mean, this image?
It’s not at all exclusive to Phoebe and Petrovsky - it’s used as a generic female character picture. It represents the Querulous Theologian, the Meticulous Student, and Fadgett & Daughters too.
So, it happened in a letter—one intended to swindle money out of people—where Madame Petrovsky was talking about Zee and all that. Everything seemed fine, but then she asked my OC: “So, how are the plans coming along?” My OC didn’t answer a thing, and that gave me chills! I mean, think about it: she’s my OC’s friend—there’s no reason for my OC to hide her plans from her! It immediately reminded me of the fake Contezza! Do you get it now?
Oh, I see! Well, take a look at my other comment and you’ll understand why I’m suspicious—but even so, I’m still feeling wary, just so you know!
I have no idea what you’re talking about.
The “card” I’m referring to is a card from a deck—you know, a playing card. Do you get it now? If not, just tell me what you didn’t understand and I’ll explain!
You haven’t referred to a card in any of your previous posts, so that doesn’t help.
When you mention getting a letter, do you mean a Sunless Sea or Fallen London event? Can you find the wiki page for what you’re talking about? It’s hard for anyone to know the context of what you mean from this description.
I’m referring to this Opportunity Card that my OC picked up—she was already suspicious of this Madame Petrovsky, given that there was already an impostor among the sisters in the Neath; why couldn’t this Madame Petrovsky be another one? And this card only reinforces that: A Successful Evening October 17, 2026 (Grudge) Add tag You are a seasoned professional. For you, parting most of these people from their money is a breeze. What’s interesting, however, is the conversation itself. Madame Petrovsky speaks persuasively about the lands beyond the Unterzee—the landscapes to be visited, the peculiar peoples and beliefs. At the end, she turns to you. “And how are your plans coming along?” she asks.
.. seems to be this one ..?
Helena Petrovna Blavatsky was a real occultist who believed in, or at least claimed to believe in, a lot of foreign mysticism she basically made up. When Petrovsky talks ‘persuasively’ about the people beyond the Neath, it’s in the context of her real life counterpart being a prolific bullshitter, not that she actually knows what she’s talking about. When she asks about your plans, it has nothing to do with Phoebe or Hunter’s Keep - you are a Fallen London PC, it’s a safe bit of small talk to assume you are going to go overzees at some point in the near future and have plans about it.
But then why is Phoebe’s image associated with Madame Petrovsky? And it’s “Madame Petrovsky,” not “Madame Petrovna Blavatsky.” For your information, my OC has actually met Phoebe and knows about the well—and much more—so this isn’t just empty talk; it’s a suspicion that something is wrong.
Their images aren’t ‘associated’ with each other, they’re using the same default art because Failbetter has limited resources. There are some characters who have unique portraits that are only used for them or things associated with them; the Bluestocking image isn’t one of those images.
The names are different, because Failbetter does not usually use the exact name someone was known as historically. Charles John Huffam Dickens is Mr Huffam, not Charles Dickens. Sigismund Schlomo Freud is Dr Schlomo, not Sigmund Freud. Changing which of Blavatsky’s names got conjugated which way - Petrovna Blavatsky to Petrovsky - is entirely in keeping with this pattern.
Also, while you can have fun role-playing (it’s part of the game!), the characters always say the same things in a trackable way. You get that text from Petrovsky whether or not you have been to Hunter’s Keep. It has nothing to do with Phoebe, and your roleplay is not actually giving you access to more information than anyone else has.
I fear the depths you believe you have accessed in your role play may simply not be there.
Tenshi, a major mistake you’ve made with your first few posts in this thread - and in multiple other threads you’ve made - is assuming everyone knows what you’re talking about already, and that you don’t need to explain things in detail because we already get it. The problems with this are twofold.
-Even with how much some of us know about Fallen London, we don’t know where you are in it, so information that’s fresh in your mind because you just ran a certain carousel might not spring to our minds because whatever carousel you just did is something we haven’t embarked on in a long time. This is most obvious with your many posts, in this thread and in others, about Hunter’s Keep, a place many of us stopped going to relatively early because there’s not much we can acquire there that cannot be more quickly acquired elsewhere.
-You can barely write. It’s hard for us to parse what you’re saying because of your poor grasp of the English language, your ideas are of dubious quality, your theories are potato, and your seeming assumption that we have a front-row seat to your thought process makes it hard for us to discern what you’re trying to say even after we’ve picked apart what seems to be the meaning of your words.
The very first post you made in this thread shows the first of those problems - you didn’t give any evidence for your theory, you didn’t bring up what made you think of it or what brought it to mind, you just asked your question as though Petrovsky being Phoebe was the most obvious thing or an idea we’d already be familiar with.
You also don’t seem to understand the purpose of spoiler tags or the etiquette surrounding their use. The placement of your spoiler tag leaves the reader with no idea if clicking it will spoil them on any particular storyline, or any carousel, or any E.S., or any Ambition - it’s just there, utterly inscrutable.
Your post about your O.C. not replying to Petrovsky putting you on edge genuinely makes me worry about your connection to reality - do you understand that Fallen London isn’t real, that it’s a video game where everything that happens is deliberately written by real people and shared with the masses, and that not everything you see in it is deliberately tailored to fit your exact experiences? B_____ hell, you’re practically jumping at shadows!
i was going to reply to this with just “what” but i thought about it and this is a great example of you just saying things and expecting all of us will be on the same page as you & know what you’re talking about. I haven’t been to Hunter’s Keep at all in at least a month and I haven’t taken a full tour of it in far longer, but I’ve read a good bit about it - both its presentation in Fallen London and its presentation in Sunless Sea - and I have no memory of any mention of anything like what you’re describing, yet you seemingly don’t view explaining yourself as being necessary to any degree so I’m simply left clueless as to what may have even given you such a misconception.
It’s not. This was already posted.
You should know this because you replied to that post. This implies that either you are a troll of some kind, you are not reading the entirety of posts you reply to, or you forgot that post in the span of eleven hours.
Oh, my delightful friend! First of all, I use Google Translate to communicate with you all. Secondly, just because it’s fiction doesn’t mean I can’t have feelings or become attached to a particular character. Thirdly, I’m not a troll; I just had a question that needed answering to clear up any suspicion. Fourth, it’s been a long time since I played Hunter’s Keep, so I don’t remember everything (aside from the parts that really left an impression on me). And fifth—why are you all so focused only on things to acquire? There’s a whole beautiful world of story and discovery in Fallen London! And sixth—apologies for the mistake of assuming you already knew everything.